Loading rankings...
Ranking
2025–26
25\u201326
2025
2026
The best books, according to the critics
01 — INFLUENCE MAP
Who moves the needle?
The most active critics in the 2025–26 season. Coverage volume, average generosity, and timing position.
KEY INSIGHT
Early reviewers with high coverage are tastemakers. They don't follow consensus — they create it.
Note: All scores are generated by EdgarScore’s AI based on the content of each written review. Critics do not assign numerical scores — the algorithm interprets their judgment.
Loading critic data
02 — HEAD-TO-HEAD
The definitive comparison
Select two books and compare across 6 dimensions.
KEY INSIGHT
Score alone never tells the full story. A book with fewer reviews but higher T1 coverage often has more authority.
vs
03 — VELOCITY RADAR
The shape of attention
Review accumulation curves reveal campaign strategy.
KEY INSIGHT
Books that reach 3 reviews within 14 days have a 73% higher chance of entering the Top 20.
04 — SOURCE DNA
Editorial fingerprints
Six dimensions reveal a publication's editorial personality.
KEY INSIGHT
A source with high speed but low consensus is a bold tastemaker.
05 — CONTRARIAN INDEX
Who thinks differently?
Not who scores low — who scores differently from everyone else. The Contrarian Index measures the average distance between a critic's score and the average of all other critics who reviewed the same book.
KEY INSIGHT
Two critics can read the same novel and reach opposite conclusions — both with valid arguments. That tension is what makes criticism alive.
Analyzing divergence
Note: An index of 1.0 means, on average, this critic diverges by 1 full point from their peers.
06 — PUBLISHER SCORECARD
Who's winning?
Average EdgarScore, Top 20 rate, tier coverage breakdown.
KEY INSIGHT
Small publishers with high scores and strong T1 coverage are punching above their weight.
MIN BOOKS
YEAR
Loading publishers
07 — AUTHOR MAGNETISM
Who captures attention fastest?
Books that accumulate reviews in concentrated bursts.
KEY INSIGHT
5 reviews in 10 days signals a intense campaign.
WINDOW
YEAR
Loading magnetism
08 — BOOK PERSISTENCE
Which books endure?
The long tail of critical attention.
KEY INSIGHT
Persistent books rarely have the highest launch velocity. Their strength is staying power.
MINIMUM
YEAR
Loading persistence
09 — ALTERNATIVE RANKINGS
Hidden champions
Filter by tier, region, and genre to discover what changes.
KEY INSIGHT
Books that rank higher under T1-only filters have elite critical backing.
TIER
REGION
GENRE
YEAR